What does "unjust or inappropriate" mean for deviation purposes?

Family Code § 4057(a) requires the guideline amount to be "unjust or inappropriate" due to special circumstances. Courts interpret this as requiring a showing that applying the formula would produce an unfair result that doesn't serve the child's best interests. The bar is intentionally high to ensure predictability and fairness in most cases.

Can I request a deviation just because I think the guideline amount is too high?

No. Simply believing the amount is high is not sufficient. You must prove specific factors under FC § 4057(b) apply to your case and that the guideline creates an unjust result. General financial strain or difficulty paying is not grounds for deviation—the formula already accounts for income levels.

How often do California courts actually grant deviations?

Deviations are relatively rare. The guideline formula is presumed correct, and courts grant deviations only when compelling evidence shows special circumstances. High-income cases and extraordinary hardships have higher success rates, but typical middle-income cases rarely qualify for deviation.

Do I need an attorney to request a deviation?

While not legally required, deviation requests involve complex legal arguments citing case law and statutory interpretation. Courts expect written findings and legal analysis. Most successful deviations involve attorney representation due to the evidentiary and procedural requirements.

Can the court deviate on its own without either parent requesting it?

Yes, under FC § 4057(a), the court may deviate sua sponte (on its own motion) if it finds the guideline inappropriate. However, this is very rare. The court must still comply with the written findings requirement and allow both parents to be heard before ordering a deviation.

If a deviation is granted, how long does it last?

A deviation order remains in effect until modified by a subsequent court order. Either parent can request modification if circumstances change materially (typically a 20% income change or other significant factor). The deviation doesn't automatically expire but can be challenged through a modification proceeding.

What evidence do I need to prove extraordinary hardship?

You need documented proof of mandatory expenses not accounted for in the guideline formula. Examples: itemized medical bills with insurance EOBs showing non-coverage, court orders for support obligations to others, proof of elderly parent dependency, property loss documentation. General bills or discretionary spending won't qualify.

Can a deviation be appealed?

Yes. Either parent can appeal a deviation order under CCP § 904.1. However, appellate courts give trial courts substantial discretion in deviation determinations. Appeals typically succeed only if the trial court failed to issue written findings or applied the law incorrectly—not merely because the appellate court might have weighed factors differently.

Family Code § 4057

California Child Support Deviation Factors

Understand when and how California courts can deviate from the guideline child support formula under Family Code § 4057, including extraordinary circumstances, high-income cases, and the procedural requirements for requesting a deviation.

High Legal Standard

Deviations from the guideline formula are rare and require proving the guideline would be "unjust or inappropriate." Courts presume the guideline is correct. Most deviation requests are denied without exceptional circumstances and strong legal arguments.

See Valid Grounds Review Standard Formula

Deviation Basics

Legal Basis

FC § 4057

Rebuttal of guideline calculation

California Family Code § 4057

Standard Required

High Bar

Unjust or Inappropriate

Must show guideline would be improper

FC § 4057(a)

Burden of Proof

Party Seeking Deviation

Must present evidence and legal argument

FC § 4057(b)

Written Findings

Required

Mandatory

Court must explain deviation reasons

FC § 4056

Appeal Rights

Both Parents

Deviation orders are reviewable

CCP § 904.1

Frequency

Case-Specific

Rare in typical income cases

California Judicial Council

Valid Grounds for Deviation

Extraordinary High Income

When combined parental income far exceeds needs for child's reasonable lifestyle

Legal Basis: FC § 4057(b)(3)

Example: Combined income of $500,000/year; guideline support may exceed child's actual needs

Note: Court may cap support at amount reasonably related to child's lifestyle and needs

Special Hardship

Extraordinary expenses or losses not considered in the guideline formula

Legal Basis: FC § 4071

Example: Catastrophic medical costs, major property loss, support for elderly parent

Note: Must demonstrate expenses are mandatory and not discretionary

Children from Other Relationships

Parent has court-ordered support obligations for other children

Legal Basis: FC § 4057.5

Example: Paying $1,500/month for children from previous marriage

Note: Income deduction for other children is already built into formula; rarely grounds for deviation

Asset Disparities

Significant differences in assets affecting ability to pay or need for support

Legal Basis: FC § 4057(b)(5)

Example: One parent owns $2M home outright; other rents studio apartment

Note: California focuses on income, not assets, for support; difficult to establish

Time-Share Arrangements

K-factor adjustments may not fully reflect actual cost-sharing

Legal Basis: FC § 4057(b)(2)

Example: Near-equal timeshare with high fixed costs duplicated in both homes

Note: K-factor already accounts for timeshare; must show specific costs not captured

Educational Costs

Private school or special educational needs not covered by add-ons

Legal Basis: FC § 4062(b)

Example: $30,000/year private high school tuition

Note: Educational costs are discretionary; deviation not guaranteed

Deviation Request Procedure

Step 1

File Motion or Request for Order (FL-300)

Submit formal request to deviate from guideline with supporting declaration

Documents: FL-300, FL-150 (Income Declaration), evidence of deviation grounds

Timing: At least 16 court days before hearing

Step 2

Prepare Legal Argument

Draft points and authorities citing FC § 4057 and explaining why guideline is unjust/inappropriate

Documents: Memorandum of points and authorities, case law citations

Timing: Filed with motion or at hearing

Step 3

Provide Evidence

Submit financial records, expense documentation, expert reports (if applicable)

Documents: Bank statements, tax returns, medical bills, school invoices

Timing: With motion or via preliminary declaration of disclosure

Step 4

Serve Other Parent

Personal service of all documents on opposing party or their attorney

Documents: All filed documents + proof of service (FL-335)

Timing: 16 court days before hearing (personal service)

Step 5

Opposing Party Response

Other parent files responsive declaration (FL-320) supporting or opposing deviation

Documents: FL-320, counter-evidence, legal arguments

Timing: 9 court days before hearing

Step 6

Court Hearing

Present oral argument, examine evidence, testimony (if allowed)

Documents: Trial exhibits, witness lists (if evidentiary hearing)

Timing: Scheduled hearing date

Step 7

Written Findings

Court issues order with detailed explanation of deviation reasons per FC § 4056

Documents: Findings and Order After Hearing (FL-340)

Timing: Within 90 days of hearing (Family Code § 217)

Real Case Examples

High-Income Professional

Combined income $800,000/year; 2 children ages 8 and 10

Guideline Amount: $8,500/month

Deviation Request: Noncustodial parent requests reduction to $5,000/month

Court Ruling: Partial deviation granted: $6,500/month

Court found $8,500 exceeds reasonable needs; reduced to align with upper-middle-class lifestyle benchmark

Case Citation: In re Marriage of Hubner (2001) 94 Cal.App.4th 175

Medical Hardship

Parent has $15,000/month in ongoing medical expenses for chronic condition

Guideline Amount: $2,800/month

Deviation Request: Payor parent requests reduction to $1,200/month

Court Ruling: Deviation denied

Medical expenses already deductible under FC § 4059; no extraordinary hardship shown beyond formula

Case Citation: County of Kern v. Castle (1999) 75 Cal.App.4th 1442

Private School Costs

Child enrolled in $40,000/year private boarding school

Guideline Amount: $3,200/month

Deviation Request: Custodial parent requests upward deviation to $6,500/month

Court Ruling: Deviation granted in part: $4,800/month

Child attended same school during marriage; continuation serves best interests; split proportionally

Case Citation: In re Marriage of Bardzik (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1291

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Resources

California Child Support Formula

Learn the standard guideline calculation before exploring deviations

Child Support Calculator

Calculate guideline support to determine baseline amount

Child Support Modification

How to request changes to an existing support order

SB 343 Policy Updates

Understand the 2024 changes to California child support law

Legal References & Review

Content Review

Last Reviewed: January 18, 2025
Next Review: July 18, 2025
Reviewed By: Family Law Research Team

Content reviewed for accuracy and compliance with California Family Law as of January 2025

Effective Law

Family Code § 4057, § 4056, § 4071

Deviation standards subject to judicial interpretation. Consult case law for your county.

Primary Legal Sources:

California Family Code § 4057 - Rebuttal of Guideline(statute)
California Family Code § 4056 - Written Findings Requirement(statute)
California Family Code § 4071 - Special Hardship(statute)
California Courts Self-Help - Child Support(official resource)

Internal Research

This content includes case law analysis and deviation factor interpretation. For formula basics, see our Formula Guide. To calculate guideline support, use our California Calculator.